Extracted Annotations

Annotation Summary

15

Total Annotations

1

Ontologies

By Method:

llm_enhanced: 15

Proethica-Intermediate Ontology 15 annotations

Concept	Text Match	Method	Confidence	Status	Actions
Professional Role	"City Engineer" City Engineer is a specific professional role in municipal engineering with defined responsibilities and ethical obligations.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Agent A material entity capable of bearing roles and performing intentional actions in professional contex...	"Engineer D, a licensed professional engineer" Engineer D is clearly identified as an agent - a professional capable of bearing roles and performing intentional actions in engineering contexts.	llm_enhanced claude	95%	pending 09/05 00:02
Ethical Principle A fundamental moral rule or standard that guides ethical reasoning and decision-making in engineerin...	"Is it ethical for Engineer D to accept employment with AE&R?" This question directly addresses ethical principles regarding professional conduct and potential conflicts of interest in employment transitions.	llm_enhanced claude	85%	pending 09/05 00:02
Ethical Principle A fundamental moral rule or standard that guides ethical reasoning and decision-making in engineerin...	"Is it ethical for Engineer D to be immediately, directly involved with AE&R's projects with the City?" This question explicitly concerns ethical principles about conflicts of interest and professional conduct in client relationships.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Loyalty The professional duty to act in faithful support of legitimate interests of one's employer, clients,...	"Act for each employer or client as faithful agents or trustees" This NSPE code provision directly defines the principle of loyalty - the duty to act faithfully in support of employer and client interests.	llm_enhanced claude	95%	pending 09/05 00:02
Obligation An information content entity expressing required actions or behaviors in professional contexts. Thi...	"Act for each employer or client as faithful agents or trustees" This represents a professional obligation - a required behavior for engineers in their relationships with employers and clients.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Ethical Conduct The observable behavior and actions of an engineer that align with professional ethical standards, c...	"Conduct themselves honorably, responsibly, ethically, and lawfully so as to enhance the honor, reputation, and usefulness of the profession" This directly describes ethical conduct - behavior that aligns with professional ethical standards and moral principles governing engineering.	llm_enhanced claude	95%	pending 09/05 00:02
Obligation An information content entity expressing required actions or behaviors in professional contexts. Thi...	"Engineers shall disclose all known or potential conflicts of interest that could influence or appear to influence their judgment or the quality of their services" This establishes a professional obligation - engineers are required to disclose conflicts of interest.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Obligation An information content entity expressing required actions or behaviors in professional contexts. Thi...	"Engineers shall not solicit or accept financial or other valuable consideration, directly or indirectly, from outside agents in connection with the work for which they are responsible" This defines a professional obligation prohibiting certain financial arrangements that could compromise professional integrity.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Obligation An information content entity expressing required actions or behaviors in professional contexts. Thi...	"Engineers shall not solicit or accept a contract from a governmental body on which a principal or officer of their organization serves as a member" This establishes a professional obligation to avoid conflicts of interest in governmental contracting.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Confidentiality The ethical obligation to protect sensitive information entrusted by clients, employers, or colleagu...	"Engineers shall not disclose, without consent, confidential information concerning the business affairs or technical processes of any present or former client or employer" This directly defines the principle of confidentiality - the obligation to protect sensitive information from unauthorized disclosure.	llm_enhanced claude	95%	pending 09/05 00:02
Obligation An information content entity expressing required actions or behaviors in professional contexts. Thi...	"Engineers shall not disclose, without consent, confidential information concerning the business affairs or technical processes of any present or former client or employer" This represents a professional obligation requiring engineers to maintain confidentiality of sensitive information.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Obligation An information content entity expressing required actions or behaviors in professional contexts. Thi...	"Engineers shall not, without the consent of all interested parties, promote or arrange for new employment or practice in connection with a specific project for which the engineer has gained particular and specialized knowledge" This establishes a professional obligation regarding employment transitions and use of specialized knowledge gained from previous positions.	llm_enhanced claude	90%	pending 09/05 00:02
Code of Ethics A formal document established by a professional engineering organization that articulates the ethica...	"NSPE Code of Ethics References" This explicitly references the NSPE Code of Ethics, which is a formal document articulating ethical principles and standards for engineering conduct.	llm_enhanced claude	95%	pending 09/05 00:02
Event A discrete occurrence or incident within engineering practice that has ethical significance, involvi...	"Engineer D announces plans to step down as the City Engineer and indicates that they accepted a position at an unnamed engineering firm" This describes a significant event in professional practice - an employment transition that has ethical implications for all parties involved.	llm_enhanced claude	80%	pending 09/05 00:02

Batch Actions

Use LLM annotation to identify ontology concepts in this case text.

Back to Case All Cases