Duty To Report Safety Violations

Case 84 Source
Back to Case

Document Structure

4

Sections

4/4

With Embeddings

100%

Coverage

384D

Dimensions
Embeddings use 384D local model for precedent matching
Document Sections

Content Length
106 chars
HTML Length
106 chars
Plain Text Length
106 chars
Embedding Dimension
384 Compatible
Created
2026-02-13 16:13
Updated
2026-02-13 16:13
Content Preview
It was unethical for Engineer A not to report the safety violations to the appropriate public authorities.

Content Length
7248 chars
HTML Length
7865 chars
Plain Text Length
7246 chars
Embedding Dimension
384 Compatible
Created
2026-02-13 16:13
Updated
2026-03-02 23:20
Content Preview
The facts presented in this case raise a conflict between two basic ethical obligations of an engineer: The obligation of the engineer to be faithful to the client and not to disclose confidential information concerning the business affairs of a client without that client's consent, and the obligation of the engineer to hold paramount the public health and safety. Section III.4 can be clearly understood to mean that an engineer has an ethical obligation not to disclose confidential information concerning the business affairs of any present client without the consent of that client. That provision makes no specific exception to the language. For example, the drafters of the Code could have provided exceptional circumstances where such confidential information could be disclosed by the engineer; however no such provisions have been included. There are various rationale for the non-disclosure language contained in the Code. Engineers, in the performance of their professional services, act as "agents" or "trustees" to their clients. They are privy to a great deal of information and background concerning the business affairs of their client. The disclosure of confidential information could be quite detrimental to the interests of their client and therefore engineers as "agents" or "trustees" of such information are expected to maintain the confidential nature of the information revealed to them in the course of rendering their professional services. On numerous occasions, this Board has interpreted the language contained in Sections II.4. and III.4. particularly in the context of the obligations of employed engineers to maintain the confidences of their employer particularly with regard to certain confidential information which might be made available to the engineer during the course of employment as in Case 61-8. However, more recently, the Board has interpreted this language in the context of the relationships owed by the engineer in private practice to the client....

Content Length
1228 chars
HTML Length
1228 chars
Plain Text Length
1230 chars
Embedding Dimension
384 Compatible
Created
2026-02-13 16:13
Updated
2026-02-13 16:13
Content Preview
Engineer A is retained to investigate the structural integrity of a 60-year old occupied apartment building which his client is planning to sell. Under the terms of the agreement with the client, the structural report written by Engineer A is to remain confidential. In addition, the client makes clear to Engineer A that the building is being sold "as is" and he is not planning to take any remedial action to repair or renovate any system within the building prior to its sale.Engineer A performs several structural tests on the building and determines that the building is structurally sound. However, during the course of providing services, the client confides in Engineer A and informs him that the building contains deficiencies in the electrical and mechanical systems which violate applicable codes and standards. While Engineer A is not an electrical nor mechanical engineer, he does realize those deficiencies could cause injury to the occupants of the building and so informs the client.In his report, Engineer A makes a brief mention of his conversation with the client concerning the deficiencies; however, in view of the terms of the agreement, Engineer A does not report the safety violations to any third party.

Content Length
104 chars
HTML Length
104 chars
Plain Text Length
104 chars
Embedding Dimension
384 Compatible
Created
2026-02-13 16:13
Updated
2026-02-13 16:13
Content Preview
Was it ethical for Engineer A not to report the safety violations to the appropriate public authorities?
Similar Cases

By discussion section embedding (cosine similarity)

74%
65%
56%
Full Similarity Analysis

D-tuple Component Breakdown

218

Total Entities

9/9

Components Populated

9/9

With Embeddings

Combined Embedding
Roles R
w=0.12 384D
Building Occupants Stakeholder
Residents of the 60-year-old occupied apartment building who are exposed to injury risk from the undisclosed...
Building Owner Selling As-Is Client
Client retaining Engineer A under a confidentiality agreement to assess the building for sale; explicitly states the...
Engineer A Confidentiality-Bound Structural Safety Discovering Engineer
Retained under a confidentiality agreement to assess structural integrity of a 60-year-old occupied apartment...
Engineer A Confidentiality-Bound Public Safety Inaction Engineer
Engineer A received confidential information from the client during professional service delivery that implicated...
Client Confidential Safety Information Transmitting Client
The client transmitted confidential business information to Engineer A during the course of professional service...
Case 84-5 Engineer Construction Phase Safety Recommendation Abandoning Engineer
Referenced analogously from Case 84-5: an engineer who recommended a full-time on-site project representative for a...
Case 84-5 Client Cost-Objecting Safety Staffing Refusing Client
Referenced from Case 84-5: a client who retained an engineer for complete engineering services, was advised that a...
Confidentiality-Bound Public Safety Inaction Engineer
A licensed professional engineering role in which an engineer, while providing professional services to a client,...
Confidential Safety Information Transmitting Client
A client stakeholder role in which a party retaining an engineer for professional services transmits confidential...
9 entities
Principles P
w=0.2 384D
Public Welfare Paramount
Fundamental principle requiring engineers to hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public above...
Confidentiality Principle
Must be balanced against public safety obligations and legal disclosure requirements.
Client Notification Obligation for Discovered Safety Hazard
Relational principle requiring engineers acting as faithful agents of their clients to advise clients in writing of...
Confidentiality Expectation Source-of-Information Distinction Principle
Relational principle establishing that the strength of a client's legitimate expectation of confidentiality over...
Competence Boundary Recognition and Escalation Obligation
Professional virtue principle establishing that when an engineer assigned to review or approve another engineer's...
Scope-of-Work Limitation as Incomplete Ethical Defense
Professional principle establishing that a contractual scope-of-work limitation does not constitute a complete...
Non-Acquiescence to Unsafe Client Directives
Professional principle requiring engineers to refuse to continue work on a project when a client insists on...
Client Direction Does Not Authorize Ethical Violation
Professional principle establishing that an engineer's receipt of explicit client instructions to perform work in a...
Confidentiality Principle Invoked By Engineer A Under Contractual Agreement
Engineer A invoked the confidentiality agreement with the client to justify not reporting electrical and mechanical...
Code Exception Clause Activation Obligation Failed By Engineer A
Engineer A failed to recognize and activate the ethics code's public safety exception clause, treating the general...
Client Notification Obligation Partially Discharged By Engineer A Brief Mention
Engineer A made only a 'brief mention' of his conversation with the client concerning the electrical and mechanical...
Insistence on Remedial Action or Withdrawal Obligation Not Met By Engineer A
Engineer A failed to insist that the client remediate the electrical and mechanical code violations before...
Post-Client-Refusal Escalation Assessment Not Conducted By Engineer A
After the client made clear that no remedial action would be taken and the building would be sold 'as is,' Engineer...
Faithful Agent Obligation Within Ethical Limits Misapplied By Engineer A
Engineer A treated the faithful agent obligation as requiring compliance with the client's confidentiality agreement...
Non-Acquiescence to Unsafe Client Directive Violated By Engineer A
Engineer A acquiesced to the client's 'as is' sale directive and refusal to remediate electrical and mechanical code...
Third-Party Affected Party Direct Notification Obligation Not Discharged By Engineer A
Engineer A failed to directly notify building occupants of the electrical and mechanical code violations that could...
Confidentiality Principle Engaged by Client Transmission to Engineer A
The Board finds that Section III.4.'s confidentiality obligation is fully engaged in this case because the client...
Ethics Code Internal Cross-Provision Integration Obligation
Fundamental ethical principle establishing that no single provision of an engineering ethics code may be read in...
Public Welfare Paramount Invoked in Engineer A Confidentiality-Safety Conflict
The Board invokes the 'paramount' language of Section I.1. to establish that Engineer A's public safety obligation...
Confidentiality Expectation Source-of-Information Distinction Applied in Case 82-2 Contrast
The Board distinguishes the present case from Case 82-2 by reference to the source of the confidential information:...
Non-Acquiescence to Unsafe Client Directives - Engineer A Should Have Refused to Continue
The Board holds that Engineer A should have refused to continue work on the building assessment project when the...
Confidentiality Agreement Non-Supersession - Engineer A's Contractual Confidentiality vs. Imminent Danger
The confidentiality agreement under which Engineer A was retained does not supersede the professional obligation to...
Confidentiality Non-Applicability to Public Danger Disclosure
Relational principle establishing that professional confidentiality obligations - which protect clients' technical...
Code Exception Clause Activation for Public Safety Disclosure
Relational principle establishing that engineering ethics codes contain explicit exception clauses that...
Confidentiality Agreement Non-Supersession of Imminent Danger Disclosure Obligation
Relational principle establishing that a contractual or attorney-directed confidentiality obligation assumed by an...
Passive Acquiescence After Safety Notification as Independent Ethical Failure
Professional principle establishing that an engineer who discovers safety violations or hazardous conditions,...
Insistence on Client Remedial Action or Project Withdrawal Obligation
Professional principle establishing that when an engineer discovers safety violations or hazardous conditions during...
Post-Client-Refusal Escalation Assessment Obligation
Professional principle requiring engineers who have disclosed a material public safety or welfare risk to a client...
Faithful Agent Obligation Within Ethical Limits
Relational principle requiring engineers to act as faithful agents and trustees of their clients and employers -...
Third-Party Affected Party Direct Notification Obligation
Professional principle requiring engineers who discover safety deficiencies affecting identifiable third parties -...
Public Welfare Paramount Invoked By Engineer A In Occupied Building Safety Context
Engineer A recognized that electrical and mechanical code violations in an occupied 60-year-old apartment building...
Confidentiality Non-Applicability to Public Danger Disclosure Violated By Engineer A
Engineer A's failure to report electrical and mechanical code violations to appropriate authorities violated the...
Confidentiality Agreement Non-Supersession Principle Violated By Engineer A
Engineer A treated the contractual confidentiality agreement as superseding his professional duty to disclose...
Passive Acquiescence After Safety Notification Independent Ethical Failure By Engineer A
Engineer A informed the client of the electrical and mechanical deficiencies but then proceeded passively - making...
Confidentiality Source-of-Information Distinction Applied To Client Voluntary Disclosure
The electrical and mechanical deficiency information was voluntarily disclosed by the client to Engineer A during...
Competence Boundary Recognition Partially Discharged By Engineer A
Engineer A recognized that electrical and mechanical engineering fell outside his competence as a structural...
Scope-of-Work Limitation Invoked As Incomplete Defense By Engineer A
Engineer A's structural scope of work did not cover electrical and mechanical systems, but he had actual knowledge...
Client Direction Does Not Authorize Ethical Violation Applied To Engineer A Confidentiality Reliance
Engineer A relied on the client's confidentiality agreement and 'as is' sale directive to justify not reporting...
Law-or-Code-Authorized Disclosure Exception to Confidentiality Obligation
Relational principle establishing that an engineer's obligation to maintain client confidentiality is subject to an...
Client-Transmitted Confidentiality Stronger Obligation Principle
Relational principle establishing that when confidential information reaches an engineer through direct voluntary...
Going-Along Prohibition When Safety Concerns Are Real
Professional virtue principle establishing that when an engineer has identified a genuine public safety concern and...
Paramount Safety Obligation Hierarchy Supremacy Principle
Fundamental ethical principle establishing that the word 'paramount' in the engineering ethics code's public safety...
Appropriate Authority Notification When Professional Judgment Overruled on Safety
Professional virtue principle establishing that when an engineer's professional judgment on a matter of public...
Appropriate Authority Notification When Professional Judgment Overruled - Engineer A Obligation
The Board identifies notification of the appropriate authority as a specific step Engineer A was obligated to take -...
Code Exception Clause Activation - Section II.1.c. Releases Engineer A from Confidentiality
The Board identifies Section II.1.c.'s exception clause - which releases the engineer from confidentiality when...
Competing Code Provision Contextual Balancing - III.4 vs. II.1.a. vs. II.1.c.
The Board engages in explicit cross-provision balancing of three Code sections - Section III.4 (confidentiality),...
Passive Acquiescence Ethical Failure - Engineer A Going Along After Client Safety Refusal
Engineer A, after discovering electrical and mechanical code violations in the occupied apartment building and being...
Insistence on Client Remedial Action or Withdrawal - Engineer A Obligation
The Board establishes that Engineer A was obligated either to insist that the client remediate the electrical and...
Post-Client-Refusal Escalation Assessment - Engineer A After 'As Is' Sale Decision
After the client indicated the building would be sold 'as is' despite the identified code violations, Engineer A was...
49 entities
Obligations O
w=0.15 384D
Engineer A Client Safety Violation Insistence or Withdrawal Failure
Engineer A was obligated either to insist that the client remediate the electrical and mechanical code violations...
Engineer A Faithful Agent Role Misapplication to Confidentiality Absolutism
Engineer A violated the prohibition on misapplying the faithful agent role by treating the client confidentiality...
Engineer A Paramount Safety Word Supremacy Hierarchy Non-Recognition
Engineer A was obligated to recognize that the NSPE Code's use of 'paramount' in Section I.1. established a...
Case 84-5 Engineer Going-Along Without Dissent Analogous Violation
The engineer in Case 84-5 was obligated to insist that the client hire a full-time on-site project representative...
Engineer A Passive Acquiescence Known Safety Violation Independent Ethical Failure
Engineer A was obligated to actively insist that the client take corrective action on the electrical and mechanical...
Engineer A Confidentiality Agreement Non-Excuse Safety Code Violation Reporting
Engineer A was obligated to recognize that the confidentiality agreement with the client did not excuse him from...
Engineer A Brief Report Mention Insufficiency Public Authority Safety Notification
Engineer A was obligated to recognize that his brief mention of the electrical and mechanical deficiencies within...
Engineer A Competing Confidentiality Safety Code Provision Contextual Balancing
Engineer A was obligated to recognize the conflict between the NSPE Code's confidentiality provision (Section III.4)...
Engineer A Post-Client-Override Public Safety Escalation Assessment
Engineer A was obligated, after the client declined to take any remedial action on the electrical and mechanical...
Engineer A Tenant Occupant Direct Notification Electrical Mechanical Violations
Engineer A was obligated to consider directly notifying the building occupants of the electrical and mechanical code...
Engineer A Scope of Work Non-Shield Electrical Mechanical Safety Disclosure
Engineer A was obligated to recognize that his structural engineering scope of work did not shield him from the...
Engineer A Client-Disclosed Safety Hazard Out-of-Scope Reporting
Engineer A was obligated to report the electrical and mechanical code violations to appropriate public authorities...
Section III.4 Confidentiality Client-Transmitted Information Engagement Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer to recognize that NSPE Code Section III.4's confidentiality obligation is...
Engineer A Ethics Code Cross-Provision Non-Vacuum Reading Failure
Engineer A was obligated to read Section III.4's confidentiality provision in conjunction with Section I.1.'s...
Engineer A Going-Along After Client Safety Refusal Independent Ethical Violation
Engineer A violated the prohibition on 'going along' by proceeding with the structural assessment engagement without...
Engineer A Competing Confidentiality-Safety Code Provision Contextual Balancing Failure
Engineer A was obligated to contextually balance Section III.4's confidentiality obligation against Section I.1.'s...
Engineer A Brief Report Mention Insufficiency for Public Authority Safety Notification
Engineer A's brief mention of the electrical and mechanical code violations in his confidential structural report...
Engineer A Client Safety Violation Insistence or Project Withdrawal
Engineer A was obligated to insist that the client remediate the electrical and mechanical code violations before...
Client-Disclosed Safety Hazard Out-of-Scope Reporting Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer who, during the course of providing professional services under a...
As-Is Sale Client Directive Safety Reporting Non-Override Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer retained to assess a building that a client intends to sell 'as is' - with...
Occupied Building Electrical-Mechanical Code Violation Occupant Injury Risk Escalation Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer who becomes aware - whether through direct observation or client disclosure...
Engineer A Out-of-Discipline Electrical Mechanical Code Violation Public Authority Reporting
Engineer A was obligated to report the electrical and mechanical code violations - disclosed to him by the client -...
Engineer A As-Is Sale Directive Safety Reporting Non-Override
Engineer A was obligated to recognize that the client's 'as is' sale directive - the client's business decision not...
Engineer A Occupied Building Electrical Mechanical Violation Occupant Escalation
Engineer A was obligated to escalate the electrical and mechanical code violations - which he knew could cause...
Engineer A Appropriate Authority Notification After Client Safety Override Failure
Engineer A was obligated to notify the appropriate public authority - such as the building code official, fire...
Section II.1.c. Law-or-Code-Authorized Confidentiality Release Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer to recognize and apply the exception clause in NSPE Code Section II.1.c.,...
Ethics Code Cross-Provision Non-Vacuum Reading Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer - and of ethics adjudicatory bodies - to interpret and apply any single...
Appropriate Authority Notification After Professional Judgment Safety Override Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer whose professional judgment on a matter of public safety has been overruled...
Going-Along Prohibition After Client Safety Refusal Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer who has identified a genuine public safety concern and whose client has...
Engineer A Post-Client-Override Public Safety Escalation Failure
After the client overrode Engineer A's implicit safety recommendation by declaring the building would be sold 'as...
Faithful Agent Role Misapplication to Confidentiality Absolutism Prohibition Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer to recognize that the 'faithful agent and trustee' role under NSPE Code...
Paramount Safety Word Supremacy Hierarchy Recognition Obligation
Duty of a licensed professional engineer to recognize that the NSPE Code's use of the word 'paramount' in Section...
Engineer A Passive Acquiescence Independent Ethical Failure
Engineer A's passive acquiescence - informing the client of electrical and mechanical code violations and then...
Engineer A Section III.4 Client-Transmitted Confidentiality Engagement Recognition
Engineer A was obligated to recognize that Section III.4's confidentiality obligation was fully engaged because the...
Engineer A Section II.1.c. Exception Clause Non-Activation Violation
Engineer A was obligated to recognize and apply Section II.1.c.'s exception clause, which released him from the...
35 entities
States S
w=0.1 384D
Domain-Specific Incompetence in Electrical and Mechanical Systems
Engineer A's lack of competence in electrical and mechanical engineering while holding structural engineering licensure
Client As-Is Sale No Remediation Intent Active
Client's explicit declaration that no remedial action will be taken on any system prior to sale, despite known code...
Public Safety at Risk from Known Code Violations in Occupied Building
The safety of current occupants of the 60-year-old apartment building who are exposed to known electrical and...
Engineer A Confidentiality vs. Public Safety Competing Duties
Engineer A's simultaneous obligations to maintain client confidentiality and to protect occupant/public safety...
Engineer A Code-Based Confidentiality Exception Activation
Engineer A's confidentiality obligation under Section III.4 and Section II.1.c, where the code's own exception...
Engineer A Passive Acquiescence to Client Safety Refusal
Engineer A's continuation of work on behalf of the client without insisting on safety remediation, withdrawing from...
Engineer A Client Cost-Driven Safety Oversight Rejection (Case 84-5 Analogy)
The analogous state from Case 84-5 referenced in the discussion, where a client refused to fund a full-time on-site...
Engineer A Paramount Safety Obligation Notification Duty
Engineer A's obligation to notify the appropriate authority when professional judgment regarding safety was...
Confidential Structural Engagement Agreement Active
Engineer A's structural report and all findings under the confidential engagement agreement
Out-of-Scope Code Violation Disclosure in Occupied Building Sale
Engineer A's knowledge of client-disclosed electrical and mechanical code violations in an occupied building being...
Confidentiality Obligation vs. Occupant Safety Competing Duties
Engineer A's simultaneous obligation to maintain client confidentiality and obligation to protect occupants from...
Confidentiality Instruction Suppressing Safety Report to Third Parties
The contractual confidentiality agreement functioning as the operative reason Engineer A withholds the safety...
Inspection-Discovered vs. Client-Disclosed Safety Information Distinction Active
The ethical weight of Engineer A's confidentiality obligation as modulated by the fact that the deficiency...
Client Relationship Established Under Confidential Structural Engagement
Engineer A's active professional relationship with the building owner, including the confidentiality obligation and...
Engineer Passive Acquiescence to Client Safety Refusal State
State in which a professional engineer, having identified a safety concern and presented it to the client, proceeds...
Code-Based Confidentiality Exception Activation State
State in which an engineer's general obligation to maintain client confidentiality is released or overridden by an...
Client-Confided Out-of-Scope Safety Violation Retention State
State in which a client voluntarily discloses to an engineer - during the course of a confidential engagement -...
17 entities
Resources Rs
w=0.1 384D
Agent-Trustee-Distinction-Framework-Instance
The Board invokes the agent/trustee characterization of the engineer-client relationship to explain the rationale...
Engineer-Safety-Recommendation-Rejection-Standard-Instance
The Board applies the principle from Case 84-5 that an engineer who 'goes along' with a client's rejection of a...
NSPE-Code-Section-I.1
Cited to establish that the engineer's obligation to protect public health and safety is 'paramount', taking...
Professional-Competence-Standard
Relevant to Engineer A's recognition that, while not an electrical or mechanical engineer, he nonetheless has...
NSPE-Code-of-Ethics
Primary normative authority governing Engineer A's competing obligations: confidentiality to client versus paramount...
Client-Confidentiality-vs-Public-Safety-Balancing-Framework
Governs how Engineer A must weigh the contractual confidentiality agreement against the paramount obligation to...
Out-of-Scope-Safety-Finding-Reporting-Standard
Directly applicable because Engineer A was retained for structural integrity only, yet became aware of electrical...
Engineer-Public-Safety-Escalation-Standard
Governs Engineer A's obligation to escalate known safety hazards to regulatory authorities or the public when the...
Applicable-Building-Electrical-Mechanical-Codes-and-Standards
The client explicitly acknowledges that the building's electrical and mechanical systems contain deficiencies that...
NSPE-Code-Section-II.1.a
Cited as the primary obligation of the engineer to protect public safety, read in conjunction with Section II.1.c to...
NSPE-Code-Section-II.1.c
Cited to establish the engineer's duty of confidentiality and the exception permitting disclosure when authorized or...
NSPE-Code-Section-II.4
Cited in the context of employed engineers' obligations to maintain employer confidences, interpreted alongside Section III.4
NSPE-Code-Section-III.4
Cited as the primary provision establishing the engineer's obligation not to disclose confidential information...
Client-Confidentiality-vs-Public-Safety-Balancing-Framework-Instance
The Board explicitly constructs and applies a framework for balancing the engineer's confidentiality obligation...
BER-Case-61-8
Cited as precedent interpreting Sections II.4 and III.4 in the context of employed engineers' obligations to...
BER-Case-82-2
Cited as precedent on client confidentiality in private practice: engineer disclosed home inspection report to real...
BER-Case-84-5
Cited as the key analogical precedent: engineer proceeded with a dangerous project after client refused to hire a...
BER-Case-85-4
Cited as one of three cases interpreting Section II.1.c, though the Board notes none of these cases fully outlined...
BER-Case-87-2
Cited as one of three cases interpreting Section II.1.c, though the Board notes none of these cases fully outlined...
19 entities
Actions A
w=0.1 384D
Accepting Confidentiality Agreement
Conducting Structural Integrity Tests
Verbally Warning Client of Danger
Documenting Conversation in Report
Declining to Report Violations Externally
5 entities
Events E
w=0.08 384D
Occupants Remain Exposed to Hazard
Client Retains Engineer A
Building Found Structurally Sound
Electrical and Mechanical Violations Disclosed
Confidential Report Completed
Engineer A's Conduct Retrospectively Condemned
6 entities
Capabilities Ca
w=0.07 384D
Engineer A Faithful Agent Role Confidentiality Absolutism Misapplication
Engineer A failed to recognize that invoking the faithful agent and trustee role to justify treating the...
Engineer A Scope-of-Work Non-Shield Safety Disclosure Non-Recognition
Engineer A failed to recognize that his structural engineering scope of work did not shield him from the obligation...
Engineer A Confidentiality Agreement Non-Excuse Safety Reporting Self-Recognition
Engineer A was required to possess the capability to recognize that the confidentiality agreement with the client...
Engineer A Brief Report Mention Insufficiency Recognition
Engineer A was required to recognize that his brief mention of the electrical and mechanical deficiencies within his...
Engineer A Competing Confidentiality Safety Provision Balancing
Engineer A was required to recognize the conflict between the NSPE Code's confidentiality provision (Section III.4)...
Engineer A Scope of Work Non-Shield Safety Disclosure Recognition
Engineer A was required to recognize that his structural engineering scope of work did not shield him from the...
Engineer A Post-Client-Refusal Regulatory Escalation Assessment
Engineer A was required to assess, after informing the client of the injury risk and receiving no remedial response...
Engineer A BER Dual-Precedent Confidentiality Safety Synthesis
Engineer A was required to retrieve and synthesize relevant BER precedent cases involving the...
Engineer A Confidentiality Pre-emption by Public Safety
Engineer A was required to recognize that the confidentiality obligation arising from his agreement with the client...
Engineer A Code Section Non-Vacuum Cross-Provision Integrated Reading Failure
Engineer A lacked or failed to exercise the capability to read Section III.4's confidentiality provision in...
Engineer A Paramount Safety Normative Hierarchy Supremacy Application Failure
Engineer A failed to recognize and apply the normative supremacy of the 'paramount' public safety obligation over...
Engineer A Confidentiality Agreement Scope Limitation for Safety Disclosure Non-Recognition
Engineer A failed to recognize that the confidentiality agreement with the client did not extend to bar disclosure...
Engineer A Post-Client-Override Public Safety Escalation Failure Instance
Engineer A failed to assess whether the client's 'as is' sale directive and refusal to remediate electrical and...
Engineer A Confidential Report Brief Mention Insufficiency Non-Recognition
Engineer A failed to recognize that his brief mention of the electrical and mechanical code violations in his...
Engineer A Dual NSPE Code Provision Simultaneous Obligation Recognition Failure
Engineer A failed to recognize that the factual situation simultaneously triggered Section III.4's confidentiality...
Engineer A BER Case 84-5 Going-Along Principle Cross-Context Analogical Application Failure
Engineer A failed to apply the BER Case 84-5 'going along' principle to his own situation - specifically, the...
Engineer A As-Is Sale Directive Safety Non-Override Recognition
Engineer A was required to recognize that the client's 'as is' sale directive - the business decision not to...
Client-Disclosed Out-of-Discipline Code Violation Injury Risk Recognition Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer who, while performing services within their primary discipline,...
As-Is Sale Business Directive Safety Reporting Non-Override Self-Recognition Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer retained to assess a building that a client intends to sell 'as is' -...
Competing Confidentiality-Safety Code Provision Contextual Balancing Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer to recognize when a single factual situation simultaneously triggers...
Occupied Building Tenant Occupant Direct Safety Notification Consideration Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer who becomes aware of code violations posing injury risk to current...
Post-Client-Refusal Public Safety Authority Escalation Assessment Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer who has informed a client of known safety code violations and...
Engineer A Out-of-Discipline Injury Risk Recognition
Engineer A possessed the capability to recognize that client-disclosed electrical and mechanical code violations -...
Engineer A Passive Acquiescence Independent Ethical Failure Recognition
Engineer A was required to recognize that making only a brief mention of the code violations in a confidential...
Engineer A Client Insistence or Withdrawal Safety Enforcement
Engineer A was required to possess the capability to insist that the client remediate the electrical and mechanical...
Engineer A Confidentiality Non-Applicability Public Danger Assessment
Engineer A was required to assess whether the confidentiality obligation arising from his agreement with the client...
Engineer A Tenant Occupant Direct Notification Consideration
Engineer A was required to consider whether the professional obligation to protect public health, safety, and...
Engineer A Client-Disclosed Safety Hazard Out-of-Scope Reporting
Engineer A was required to recognize that the electrical and mechanical code violations - disclosed to him by the...
Code Section Non-Vacuum Cross-Provision Integrated Reading Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer to recognize that no single provision of the NSPE Code of Ethics...
Paramount Safety Normative Hierarchy Supremacy Application Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer to recognize that the NSPE Code's deliberate use of the word...
Going-Along Without Dissent Independent Ethical Violation Self-Recognition Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer who has identified a genuine public safety concern - and whose client...
Client-Transmitted Confidential Information Section III.4 Engagement Boundary Identification Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer to correctly identify when Section III.4's confidentiality obligation...
BER Case 84-5 Going-Along Principle Cross-Context Analogical Application Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer or ethics reviewing body to retrieve BER Case 84-5 (engineer who...
Faithful Agent Role Confidentiality Absolutism Misapplication Non-Acquiescence Capability
Capability of a licensed professional engineer to recognize that the 'faithful agent and trustee' role under the...
Engineer A Going-Along Without Dissent Independent Ethical Violation Self-Recognition Failure
Engineer A failed to recognize that proceeding with the structural assessment engagement after the client's 'as is'...
Engineer A Client-Transmitted Confidential Information Section III.4 Engagement Boundary Identification
Engineer A possessed the capability to recognize that Section III.4's confidentiality obligation was engaged because...
Engineer A NSPE Code Section II.1.c Exception Clause Non-Activation Failure
Engineer A failed to recognize and apply Section II.1.c.'s exception clause, which released him from the...
Engineer A Client Insistence or Project Withdrawal Safety Enforcement Failure
Engineer A failed to exercise the capability to insist that the client remediate the electrical and mechanical code...
Case 84-5 Engineer Going-Along Without Dissent Analogous Violation Instance
The engineer in Case 84-5 failed to recognize that proceeding with the dangerous construction phase project without...
Engineer A Out-of-Discipline Code Violation Reporting Duty Activation Non-Recognition
Engineer A failed to recognize that the client's direct disclosure of electrical and mechanical code violations -...
Engineer A Public Safety Escalation After Client Override Failure
Engineer A failed to escalate the known electrical and mechanical code violations to appropriate public authorities...
41 entities
Constraints Cs
w=0.08 384D
Engineer A Brief Report Mention Insufficiency Public Authority Safety Notification
Engineer A's brief mention of the electrical and mechanical deficiencies within his confidential structural report...
Engineer A Scope of Work Non-Shield Electrical Mechanical Safety Disclosure
Engineer A's structural engineering scope of work did not shield him from the obligation to disclose the electrical...
Engineer A As-Is Sale Business Decision Safety Escalation Non-Override
The client's business decision to sell the apartment building 'as is' without remediation did not override or...
Engineer A Confidential Client Information Electrical Mechanical Violation Disclosure Boundary
Engineer A's ability to disclose the client-confided electrical and mechanical code violation information to third...
Engineer A Occupied Residential Building Electrical Mechanical Code Violation Occupant Injury Escalation
Engineer A was required to escalate the electrical and mechanical code violations in the occupied 60-year-old...
Client-Confided Out-of-Scope Safety Violation Confidentiality Weight Constraint
Ethical and professional constraint establishing that when a client affirmatively confides safety violation...
As-Is Sale Business Decision Safety Escalation Non-Override Constraint
Ethical constraint establishing that a client's business decision to sell a property 'as is' - without remediation...
Occupied Residential Building Electrical-Mechanical Code Violation Occupant Injury Escalation Constraint
Safety and ethical constraint requiring that a licensed professional engineer who becomes aware - whether through...
Engineer A Confidentiality Agreement Non-Bar Safety Code Violation Reporting
Engineer A's contractual confidentiality agreement with the building owner did not bar him from reporting the known...
Engineer A Passive Acquiescence Known Safety Violation Independent Ethical Failure
Engineer A committed an independent ethical violation by passively acquiescing to the client's refusal to remediate...
Engineer A Non-Expert Domain Threshold Safety Identification Electrical Mechanical
Engineer A, while not an electrical or mechanical engineer, was nonetheless competent and professionally obligated...
Engineer A Client Confidentiality Reliance Factor Escalation Modulation Client-Confided Violations
The fact that the electrical and mechanical code violations were client-confided - rather than independently...
Engineer A NSPE Code Section II.1.c Safety Exception Clause Confidentiality Override
NSPE Code Section II.1.c created an explicit code-authorized exception to Engineer A's general confidentiality...
Engineer A Public Safety Paramount Over Confidentiality Electrical Mechanical Violations
Engineer A's paramount obligation to protect the health and safety of building occupants pre-empted his duty of...
Engineer A Non-Acquiescence Client As-Is Sale Economic Override Safety
Engineer A was prohibited from acquiescing to the client's economically motivated refusal to remediate the...
Engineer A Client-Directed Ethical Violation Non-Compliance As-Is Sale Suppression
Engineer A was prohibited from complying with the client's implicit instruction - embedded in the 'as is' sale...
Engineer A Client-Confided Out-of-Scope Safety Violation Confidentiality Weight Calibration
The client-confided nature of the electrical and mechanical code violations - as opposed to violations independently...
Section III.4 Client-Transmitted Information Confidentiality Engagement Constraint
Ethical constraint establishing that NSPE Code Section III.4's confidentiality obligation is fully engaged - and...
Code Provision No-Direct-Exception Non-Absolute Interpretation Constraint
Ethical and interpretive constraint establishing that the absence of an explicit exception clause in a professional...
Paramount Safety Normative Hierarchy Confidentiality Subordination Constraint
Ethical constraint establishing that the NSPE Code's use of the word 'paramount' in Section I.1. to describe the...
Engineer A Comprehensive Code Integration Confidentiality-Safety Conflict
Engineer A was constrained to integrate all applicable Code provisions - Section III.4. (confidentiality), Section...
Going-Along Without Dissent Safety Violation Independent Ethical Prohibition Constraint
Ethical constraint establishing that a licensed professional engineer who identifies a genuine public safety concern...
BER Case 84-5 Going-Along Precedent Cross-Domain Safety Application Constraint
Ethical and analytical constraint establishing that the principle from BER Case 84-5 - that an engineer who 'goes...
Appropriate Authority Notification Post-Client-Safety-Override Mandatory Escalation Constraint
Ethical constraint establishing that a licensed professional engineer whose professional judgment on a matter of...
Engineer A Section III.4 Client-Transmitted Confidentiality Full Engagement
Engineer A's confidentiality obligation under Section III.4 was fully engaged because the client affirmatively...
Engineer A Code No-Direct-Exception Non-Absolute Interpretation
Engineer A was constrained from treating Section III.4's absence of an explicit exception clause as rendering the...
Engineer A Agent-Trustee Confidentiality Rationale Non-Absolutism
Engineer A was constrained from invoking the agent/trustee rationale for confidentiality - that engineers are privy...
Engineer A Paramount Safety Normative Hierarchy Confidentiality Subordination
Engineer A was constrained by the NSPE Code's use of 'paramount' in Section I.1. from treating the confidentiality...
Engineer A Going-Along Without Dissent Independent Ethical Violation
Engineer A violated the prohibition on going along without dissent by proceeding with the structural assessment...
Engineer A BER Case 84-5 Going-Along Precedent Cross-Domain Application
The Board applied the going-along prohibition from BER Case 84-5 - originally arising in a construction-phase...
Engineer A Appropriate Authority Notification Post-Client-Safety-Override Failure
Engineer A was constrained by the paramount professional obligation to notify the appropriate public authority -...
Engineer A NSPE Code Section II.1.c. Exception Clause Confidentiality Release
Engineer A was constrained by Section II.1.c.'s exception clause - which releases the engineer from the...
Engineer A Brief Report Mention Insufficiency for Public Authority Safety Notification
Engineer A's brief mention of the electrical and mechanical code violations in his confidential structural report...
Engineer A Public Safety Paramount Over Confidentiality Occupied Building
Engineer A's obligation to protect the public health and safety of the occupants of the 60-year-old apartment...
Engineer A Confidentiality Non-Bar to Safety-Critical Regulatory Disclosure
Engineer A's confidentiality obligation under Section III.4. and the confidentiality agreement with the client did...
Engineer A Non-Acquiescence to Client Economic Override Safety Refusal
Engineer A was constrained from acquiescing to the client's economic decision to sell the building 'as is' without...
Case 84-5 Engineer Going-Along Without Dissent Construction Phase
The engineer in Case 84-5 violated the prohibition on going along without dissent by proceeding with the dangerous...
37 entities
Embeddings: all-MiniLM-L6-v2 (384D, local) | Storage: pgvector (PostgreSQL) | Used for section and component similarity matching

© Licensed under the GNU GPL v3 | Report Issue