Entity Review - Case 148

This page shows the pre-commit working store (the raw extraction under review). This case was committed to OntServe on 2026-10-24 07:57; the committed record differs by design (deduplication, typing, and agent binding are applied at commit). View the committed record

Overview

Facts Discussion

Provenance Draft

PASS 1: Contextual Framework Facts Section

Case 148: Employment—Duty To Disclose Revocation Of Contractor License

R Roles

Classes

Individuals

S States

Classes

Individuals

Rs Resources

Classes

Individuals

Extracted Ontology Entities

20 RDF entities extracted organized by concept type

R Roles

Roles Classes

changed

Engineer

rdfs:subClassOf Roles

Linked
Engineer Role

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A professional role involving engineering practice, governed by professional licensure and the professional code, including honest representation of one's disciplinary history when seeking employment.

Inherited from EngineerRole · note

A professional role involving engineering practice and responsibilities. Occupational archetype head for all engineer specializations and extracted engineer-role leaves.

Properties

Text References:
"Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."

Confidence: 0.95

Role Kind: professional

Distinguishing Features:

Licensed professional engineering practice
Subject to honest disclosure of professional disciplinary history

Professional Scope: Professional engineering practice within the licensed discipline

Typical Qualifications: Professional Engineer license

Associated Virtues:

Honesty
Integrity

[facts] "Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm.
roleKind content: professional
distinguishingFeatures content: Licensed professional engineering practice; Subject to honest disclosure of professional disciplinary history
professionalScope content: Professional engineering practice within the licensed discipline
typicalQualifications content: Professional Engineer license
associatedVirtues content: Honesty; Integrity
confidence assessment: 0.95

changed

ContractorRole

rdfs:subClassOf Roles

Review
Contractor Role

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

The owner of a contracting firm that holds a contractor's license, responsible for the licensed contracting business and the use of its contractor license number.

Inherited from ContractorRole · note

The role borne by the party contracted to carry out construction work.

Properties

Text References:
"Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."

Confidence: 0.85

Distinguishing Features:

Holds standing through a contractor's license rather than an engineering license
Responsible for the contracting firm and its license number

[facts] "Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license.
distinguishingFeatures content: Holds standing through a contractor's license rather than an engineering license; Responsible for the contracting firm and its license number
confidence assessment: 0.85

changed

ClientRole

rdfs:subClassOf Roles

Review
Employer Role

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

An engineering firm that receives and evaluates an employment application from a professional engineer, including the applicant's answers about prior professional discipline.

Inherited from EmployerRole · note

The role borne by the employing organization as a participant in the case. The duty relationship is carried separately by :EmployerRelationshipRole. No IFC equivalent.

Properties

Text References:
"On the engineering firm employment application, there is a question asking whether the engineer “has ever been disciplined in the practice of professional engineering or had his license suspended or r..."

Confidence: 0.85

Role Kind: participant

Distinguishing Features:

Receives and evaluates employment applications
Learns facts about an applicant's licensure history after the application

[facts] "On the engineering firm employment application, there is a question asking whether the engineer “has ever been disciplined in the practice of professional engineering or had his license suspended or r..."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: On the engineering firm employment application, there is a question asking whether the engineer “has ever been disciplined in the practice of professional engineering or had his license suspended or revoked?”
roleKind content: participant
distinguishingFeatures content: Receives and evaluates employment applications; Learns facts about an applicant's licensure history after the application
confidence assessment: 0.85

Roles Individuals

Engineer F Professional Engineer Applicant

Engineer Role

Linked
Engineer Role

C148

Text References:
"Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."
"Engineer F responds in the negative on the employment application."
"Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended"

Confidence: 0.95

Actor: Engineer F

Role Class: Engineer Role

Role Kind: professional

License: Professional Engineer (engineering license never revoked or suspended)

Additional Relationships: {'type': 'appliedForEmploymentWith', 'target': 'Engineering Firm', 'quote': 'applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm'}

Case Involvement: Applied for a professional engineering position and answered in the negative to the employment application question about prior professional discipline or license suspension or revocation, while his separate contractor's license had been revoked.

Employment application response: Responded in the negative to the question whether he has ever been disciplined in the practice of professional engineering or had his license suspended or revoked

[facts] "Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Relations (structural triples)

actor: Engineer F
attributes: {'employment_application_response': 'Responded in the negative to the question whether he has ever been disciplined in the practice of professional engineering or had his license suspended or revoked'}

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm.; Engineer F responds in the negative on the employment application.; Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended
roleClass content: Engineer Role
roleKind content: professional
license content: Professional Engineer (engineering license never revoked or suspended)
additionalRelationships content: {'type': 'appliedForEmploymentWith', 'target': 'Engineering Firm', 'quote': 'applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm'}
caseInvolvement content: Applied for a professional engineering position and answered in the negative to the employment application question about prior professional discipline or license suspension or revocation, while his separate contractor's license had been revoked.
confidence assessment: 0.95

Engineering Firm Prospective Employer

Employer Role

Linked
Employer Role

C148

Text References:
"applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm"
"Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked"

Confidence: 0.9

Actor: Engineering Firm

Role Class: Employer Role

Role Kind: participant

Additional Relationships:

{'type': 'receivedEmploymentApplicationFrom', 'target': 'Engineer F', 'quote': 'applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm'}
{'type': 'learnedOfLicenseRevocationOf', 'target': 'Engineer F', 'quote': 'Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked'}

Case Involvement: Received Engineer F's employment application containing the disciplinary-history question and later learned that Engineer F's contractor's license had been revoked while his engineering license had not.

Employment application question: Asks whether the engineer has ever been disciplined in the practice of professional engineering or had his license suspended or revoked

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Relations (structural triples)

actor: Engineering Firm
attributes: {'employment_application_question': 'Asks whether the engineer has ever been disciplined in the practice of professional engineering or had his license suspended or revoked'}

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm; Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked
roleClass content: Employer Role
roleKind content: participant
additionalRelationships content: {'type': 'receivedEmploymentApplicationFrom', 'target': 'Engineer F', 'quote': 'applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm'}; {'type': 'learnedOfLicenseRevocationOf', 'target': 'Engineer F', 'quote': 'Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked'}
caseInvolvement content: Received Engineer F's employment application containing the disciplinary-history question and later learned that Engineer F's contractor's license had been revoked while his engineering license had not.
confidence assessment: 0.9

Engineer F Former Contracting Firm Owner

Contractor Role

Linked
Contractor Role

C148

Text References:
"Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."
"Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project."

Confidence: 0.9

Actor: Engineer F

Role Class: Contractor Role

License: Contractor's license (revoked)

Specialty: Fire sprinkler contracting

Case Involvement: Previously owned a fire sprinkler contracting firm whose contractor's license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual unrelated to the firm to use the contractor license number on another project.

Contractor license revocation reason: Allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project

[facts] "Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Relations (structural triples)

actor: Engineer F
attributes: {'contractor_license_revocation_reason': 'Allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project'}

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license.; Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project.
roleClass content: Contractor Role
license content: Contractor's license (revoked)
specialty content: Fire sprinkler contracting
caseInvolvement content: Previously owned a fire sprinkler contracting firm whose contractor's license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual unrelated to the firm to use the contractor license number on another project.
confidence assessment: 0.9

S States

States Classes

changed

License Revocation State

rdfs:subClassOf States

New C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A regulatory condition in which a license held by a professional or a firm has been revoked by the issuing authority, so the licensee's regulatory standing includes an accomplished revocation rather than mere exposure to discipline. Here Engineer F's contractor's license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project.

Properties

Text References:
"Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project"

Confidence: 0.92

State Category: regulatory

Persistence Type: inertial

Activation Conditions: The issuing authority revokes the license for a violation

Termination Conditions: The license is reinstated by the issuing authority

Obligation Activation: Truthful Disclosure Of Disciplinary History Obligation

Principle Transformation: The honesty principle in employment representations becomes concrete as the question of whether the accomplished revocation must be disclosed when answering questions about disciplinary history.

[facts] "Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual..."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project
stateCategory content: regulatory
persistenceType content: inertial
principleTransformation content: The honesty principle in employment representations becomes concrete as the question of whether the accomplished revocation must be disclosed when answering questions about disciplinary history.
confidence assessment: 0.92

Derived (reconstructable from the graph)

activationConditions: The issuing authority revokes the license for a violation
terminationConditions: The license is reinstated by the issuing authority
obligationActivation: Truthful Disclosure Of Disciplinary History Obligation

changed

SelectiveReportingState

rdfs:subClassOf States

Review
Selective Reporting State

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A disclosure condition in which a professional's past license discipline is not disclosed to a prospective employer, here Engineer F responding in the negative to the employment application question about discipline while his contractor's license revocation remains unknown to the engineering firm.

Inherited from SelectiveReportingState · note

A condition of what information has been disclosed among the parties, here the state in which all available information about both design approaches, including risks and benefits, has been presented to the client's leadership.

Properties

Text References:
"Engineer F responds in the negative on the employment application."

Confidence: 0.88

State Category: disclosure

Persistence Type: inertial

Activation Conditions: The professional answers the disciplinary-history question in the negative without disclosing the license revocation

Termination Conditions: The employer learns of the license revocation

Obligation Activation: Truthful Representation Obligation

Principle Transformation: The candor expected in qualifications representations becomes concrete as the question of whether the negative answer, literally confined to professional engineering discipline, withholds material information from the prospective employer.

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F responds in the negative on the employment application.
stateCategory content: disclosure
persistenceType content: inertial
principleTransformation content: The candor expected in qualifications representations becomes concrete as the question of whether the negative answer, literally confined to professional engineering discipline, withholds material information from the prospective employer.
confidence assessment: 0.88

Derived (reconstructable from the graph)

activationConditions: The professional answers the disciplinary-history question in the negative without disclosing the license revocation
terminationConditions: The employer learns of the license revocation
obligationActivation: Truthful Representation Obligation

changed

RegulatoryViolationState

rdfs:subClassOf States

Linked
Regulatory Violation State

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A condition in which a legal requirement in force for the situation has been breached, here the condition created when Engineer F allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project.

Inherited from RegulatoryViolationState · note

A condition in which a policy or requirement is in force for the situation, here City policies requiring new infrastructure projects to be developed with climate resiliency in mind.

Properties

Text References:
"he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project"

Confidence: 0.9

State Category: regulatory

Persistence Type: inertial

Activation Conditions: An unlicensed individual is permitted to use the contractor license number

Termination Conditions: The licensing authority acts on the violation and revokes the license

Principle Transformation: The licensing requirement in force is transformed from an abstract rule into a concrete breach whose consequence is the revocation of the contractor's license.

[facts] "Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project
stateCategory content: regulatory
persistenceType content: inertial
principleTransformation content: The licensing requirement in force is transformed from an abstract rule into a concrete breach whose consequence is the revocation of the contractor's license.
confidence assessment: 0.9

Derived (reconstructable from the graph)

activationConditions: An unlicensed individual is permitted to use the contractor license number
terminationConditions: The licensing authority acts on the violation and revokes the license

changed

TemporalContextState

rdfs:subClassOf States

Linked
Temporal Context State

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A temporal condition in which a professional is seeking employment with a prospective employer, so that representations made about qualifications and disciplinary history occur within the window of candidacy before any hiring decision is made. Here Engineer F applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm.

Inherited from TemporalContextState · note

A temporal condition in which a professional is seeking employment with a prospective employer, so that representations made about qualifications and past work occur within the window of candidacy before any hiring decision is made.

Properties

Text References:
"Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."

Confidence: 0.9

State Category: temporal

Persistence Type: inertial

Activation Conditions: The professional applies for a position with a prospective employer

Termination Conditions: The employer makes its hiring decision

Obligation Activation: Truthful Representation Obligation

Principle Transformation: During the candidacy window, honesty principles attach concretely to the answers given on the employment application.

[facts] "Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm.
stateCategory content: temporal
persistenceType content: inertial
principleTransformation content: During the candidacy window, honesty principles attach concretely to the answers given on the employment application.
confidence assessment: 0.9

Derived (reconstructable from the graph)

activationConditions: The professional applies for a position with a prospective employer
terminationConditions: The employer makes its hiring decision
obligationActivation: Truthful Representation Obligation

changed

PostEngagementDiscoveryState

rdfs:subClassOf States

Review
Third Party Information Discovery State

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A disclosure condition in which a party learns material information about a professional other than from the professional himself, here the engineering firm later learning of the contractor license revocation after Engineer F answered the application question in the negative.

Inherited from ThirdPartyInformationDiscoveryState · note

A disclosure condition in which a client learns material information about the retained professional from a third party rather than from the professional, here Client B learning through another party of the ethics complaint filed against Engineer A.

Properties

Text References:
"Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked"

Confidence: 0.8

State Category: disclosure

Persistence Type: inertial

Activation Conditions: The employer learns of the license revocation from a source other than the professional

Principle Transformation: Once the employer holds the information independently, the truthfulness of the earlier negative answer becomes the concrete matter for evaluation.

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked
stateCategory content: disclosure
persistenceType content: inertial
principleTransformation content: Once the employer holds the information independently, the truthfulness of the earlier negative answer becomes the concrete matter for evaluation.
confidence assessment: 0.8

Derived (reconstructable from the graph)

activationConditions: The employer learns of the license revocation from a source other than the professional

changed

RegulatoryComplianceState

rdfs:subClassOf States

Review
Regulatory Compliance State

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A condition of clean regulatory standing, here the condition that Engineer F's engineering license was never revoked or suspended, so no discipline in the practice of professional engineering is on his record.

Inherited from RegulatoryComplianceState · note

A condition of the regulatory standing of a contract or situation, including compliance, here the condition in which a contract's work aligns with the original scope of the RFQ and the resulting contract.

Properties

Text References:
"Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended"

Confidence: 0.82

State Category: regulatory

Persistence Type: inertial

Activation Conditions: No disciplinary action is taken against the engineering license

Termination Conditions: The engineering license is suspended or revoked

Principle Transformation: The clean engineering license record makes the negative answer literally accurate as to the practice of professional engineering, which frames the ethical question about the answer's completeness.

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended
stateCategory content: regulatory
persistenceType content: inertial
principleTransformation content: The clean engineering license record makes the negative answer literally accurate as to the practice of professional engineering, which frames the ethical question about the answer's completeness.
confidence assessment: 0.82

Derived (reconstructable from the graph)

activationConditions: No disciplinary action is taken against the engineering license
terminationConditions: The engineering license is suspended or revoked

changed

RegulatoryRequirementState

rdfs:subClassOf States

Review
Regulatory Requirement State

C148

Definition

Extracted from facts primary

A regulatory condition in which a licensing requirement is in force for a class of parties, here the requirement that Engineer F's fire sprinkler contracting firm hold a contractor's license.

Inherited from RegulatoryRequirementState · note

A regulatory condition in which a statute or ordinance places a requirement in force for a class of parties, here a local ordinance governing land development requiring private developers to submit plans to the city for review and approval, to pay the city's expenses for the firm's review of the drawings, and to pay for inspection services provided on the city's behalf, with those inspection services solely for ensuring infrastructure conforms to the city's design standards.

Properties

Text References:
"Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."

Confidence: 0.8

State Category: regulatory

Persistence Type: inertial

Activation Conditions: The firm engages in fire sprinkler contracting subject to the licensing requirement

Termination Conditions: The firm ceases the regulated activity

Principle Transformation: The licensing requirement is the rule whose breach through unauthorized license use led to the revocation at issue.

[facts] "Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license.
stateCategory content: regulatory
persistenceType content: inertial
principleTransformation content: The licensing requirement is the rule whose breach through unauthorized license use led to the revocation at issue.
confidence assessment: 0.8

Derived (reconstructable from the graph)

activationConditions: The firm engages in fire sprinkler contracting subject to the licensing requirement
terminationConditions: The firm ceases the regulated activity

States Individuals

changed

Firm Discovery Of Revocation

Third Party Information Discovery State

Review
Third Party Information Discovery State

C148

Text References:
"Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked"

Confidence: 0.8

State Class: Third Party Information Discovery State

Subject: Engineering firm's knowledge of Engineer F's contractor license revocation

Active Period: From the time the engineering firm learns of the revocation onward

Triggering Event: The engineering firm learns that Engineer F's contractor's license was revoked while his engineering license was never revoked or suspended

Terminated By: Not stated in the case

Affected Parties:

Engineering firm
Engineer F

Urgency Level: medium

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Later, the engineering firm learns that while Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended, Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked
stateClass content: Third Party Information Discovery State
subject content: Engineering firm's knowledge of Engineer F's contractor license revocation
activePeriod content: From the time the engineering firm learns of the revocation onward
triggeringEvent content: The engineering firm learns that Engineer F's contractor's license was revoked while his engineering license was never revoked or suspended
terminatedBy content: Not stated in the case
affectedParties content: Engineering firm; Engineer F
confidence assessment: 0.8
urgencyLevel assessment: medium

changed

Contractor License Requirement

Regulatory Requirement State

Review
Regulatory Requirement State

C148

Text References:
"Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."

Confidence: 0.78

State Class: Regulatory Requirement State

Subject: Engineer F's fire sprinkler contracting firm

Active Period: While Engineer F owned and operated the fire sprinkler contracting firm

Triggering Event: The firm engaged in fire sprinkler contracting subject to the contractor licensing requirement

Terminated By: Not stated in the case

Affected Parties: Engineer F

Urgency Level: low

[facts] "Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Previously, Engineer F was the owner of a fire sprinkler contracting firm which was required to have a contractor’s license.
stateClass content: Regulatory Requirement State
subject content: Engineer F's fire sprinkler contracting firm
activePeriod content: While Engineer F owned and operated the fire sprinkler contracting firm
triggeringEvent content: The firm engaged in fire sprinkler contracting subject to the contractor licensing requirement
terminatedBy content: Not stated in the case
affectedParties content: Engineer F
confidence assessment: 0.78
urgencyLevel assessment: low

changed

Unlicensed License Number Use

Regulatory Violation State

Linked
Regulatory Violation State

C148

Text References:
"he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project"

Confidence: 0.88

State Class: Regulatory Violation State

Subject: Engineer F's contracting firm license number as used on another project

Active Period: While the unlicensed individual was permitted to use the contractor license number

Triggering Event: Engineer F allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project

Terminated By: The licensing authority revoked the contractor's license

Affected Parties:

Engineer F
Unlicensed individual

Urgency Level: medium

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project
stateClass content: Regulatory Violation State
subject content: Engineer F's contracting firm license number as used on another project
activePeriod content: While the unlicensed individual was permitted to use the contractor license number
triggeringEvent content: Engineer F allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project
terminatedBy content: The licensing authority revoked the contractor's license
affectedParties content: Engineer F; Unlicensed individual
confidence assessment: 0.88
urgencyLevel assessment: medium

changed

Contractor License Revocation

LicenseRevocationState

New C148

Confidence: 0.92

State Class: License Revocation State

Subject: Engineer F's contractor's license

Active Period: From the revocation of the contractor's license onward

Triggering Event: The licensing authority revoked Engineer F's contractor's license because he allowed an unlicensed individual unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project

Terminated By: Not stated in the case

Affected Parties:

Engineer F
Engineering firm

Urgency Level: medium

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F’s contractor’s license was revoked because he allowed an unlicensed individual who was unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project
stateClass content: License Revocation State
subject content: Engineer F's contractor's license
activePeriod content: From the revocation of the contractor's license onward
triggeringEvent content: The licensing authority revoked Engineer F's contractor's license because he allowed an unlicensed individual unrelated to his contracting firm to use the contractor license number on another project
terminatedBy content: Not stated in the case
affectedParties content: Engineer F; Engineering firm
confidence assessment: 0.92
urgencyLevel assessment: medium

changed

Engineer F Employment Candidacy

Temporal Context State

Linked
Temporal Context State

C148

Text References:
"Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."

Confidence: 0.9

State Class: Temporal Context State

Subject: Engineer F

Active Period: From the application for the professional engineering position until the firm's hiring decision

Triggering Event: Engineer F applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm

Terminated By: The engineering firm's hiring decision, not stated in the case

Affected Parties:

Engineer F
Engineering firm

Urgency Level: low

[facts] "Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm."

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F is a professional engineer and applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm.
stateClass content: Temporal Context State
subject content: Engineer F
activePeriod content: From the application for the professional engineering position until the firm's hiring decision
triggeringEvent content: Engineer F applies for a professional engineering position with an engineering firm
terminatedBy content: The engineering firm's hiring decision, not stated in the case
affectedParties content: Engineer F; Engineering firm
confidence assessment: 0.9
urgencyLevel assessment: low

changed

Undisclosed Contractor Revocation

Selective Reporting State

Review
Selective Reporting State

C148

Text References:
"Engineer F responds in the negative on the employment application."

Confidence: 0.88

State Class: Undisclosed Disciplinary History State

Subject: Engineer F's contractor license revocation as represented on the employment application

Active Period: From Engineer F's negative response on the employment application until the engineering firm learns of the revocation

Triggering Event: Engineer F responds in the negative to the employment application question about discipline and license suspension or revocation

Terminated By: The engineering firm learns that Engineer F's contractor's license was revoked

Affected Parties:

Engineering firm
Engineer F

Urgency Level: high

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F responds in the negative on the employment application.
stateClass content: Undisclosed Disciplinary History State
subject content: Engineer F's contractor license revocation as represented on the employment application
activePeriod content: From Engineer F's negative response on the employment application until the engineering firm learns of the revocation
triggeringEvent content: Engineer F responds in the negative to the employment application question about discipline and license suspension or revocation
terminatedBy content: The engineering firm learns that Engineer F's contractor's license was revoked
affectedParties content: Engineering firm; Engineer F
confidence assessment: 0.88
urgencyLevel assessment: high

changed

Clean Engineering License Record

Regulatory Compliance State

Review
Regulatory Compliance State

C148

Text References:
"Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended"

Confidence: 0.82

State Class: Regulatory Compliance State

Subject: Engineer F's professional engineering license

Active Period: Throughout the period covered by the case

Triggering Event: Not stated in the case, the license was never subjected to discipline

Terminated By: Not stated in the case

Affected Parties:

Engineer F
Engineering firm

Urgency Level: low

Field classification (triples vs literals)

Literal extractions (kept for synthesis)

textReferences content: Engineer F’s engineering license was never revoked or suspended
stateClass content: Regulatory Compliance State
subject content: Engineer F's professional engineering license
activePeriod content: Throughout the period covered by the case
triggeringEvent content: Not stated in the case, the license was never subjected to discipline
terminatedBy content: Not stated in the case
affectedParties content: Engineer F; Engineering firm
confidence assessment: 0.82
urgencyLevel assessment: low

Rs Resources

No new resources were extracted for this section.

The extraction did not find any resources to add. This typically means the case text doesn't contain relevant resources for this section, or extraction hasn't been run yet.

Pass 1: Contextual Framework - Facts

Review extracted entities, then continue to the next step

Continue to Discussion Review

PASS 1: Contextual Framework Facts Section

R Roles

S States

Rs Resources

Extracted Ontology Entities

R Roles

Roles Classes

Roles Individuals

S States

States Classes

States Individuals

Rs Resources

Edit Entity

Pass 1: Contextual Framework - Facts