Edit Provision Concepts Template - Guidelines

Provision Concepts Guideline Extraction Viewer

Identify principles, obligations, and constraints each provision establishes

Template

Preview

History

PROVISION CONCEPT IDENTIFICATION

Analyze this provision to identify the ethical concepts it establishes.

PROVISION CODE: {{ provision_code }}
PROVISION TEXT:
{{ provision_text }}

EXISTING PRINCIPLES IN ONTOLOGY:
{{ existing_principles }}

EXISTING OBLIGATIONS IN ONTOLOGY:
{{ existing_obligations }}

=== TASK ===
Identify what ethical concepts this provision establishes. Each provision typically establishes:
- Principles: Fundamental ethical values or goals (e.g., "Public Safety", "Professional Integrity")
- Obligations: Specific duties that must be fulfilled (e.g., "Maintain Confidentiality")
- Constraints: Limitations or prohibitions (e.g., "No Conflicts of Interest")
- Capabilities: Enabled actions or permissions (e.g., "May Disclose When Required by Law")

For each concept:
1. Determine if it matches an existing ontology entity
2. If it matches, provide the existing IRI
3. If new, provide a label and definition

Respond with valid JSON:
{
    "concepts": [
        {
            "concept_type": "Obligation",
            "label": "Maintain Confidentiality",
            "definition": "Engineers shall not disclose confidential information without consent",
            "existing_match": null
        },
        {
            "concept_type": "Principle",
            "label": "Public Safety",
            "definition": "The paramount importance of protecting public safety, health, and welfare",
            "existing_match": "http://proethica.org/ontology/intermediate#PublicSafety"
        }
    ]
}

FORMATTING (ProEthica style, abbreviated): Do not use em dashes or en dashes in output text. Do not dodge that by substituting stacked parentheticals or excessive colons or semicolons. Write plain sentences: use commas, or split into two sentences.

The User prompt (template) is shown on the Template tab. Live preview is available to logged-in admins.

Version 1 2026-05-27 09:50
Strengthen style FORMATTING line: no em/en dashes AND no parenthetical-stacking / excessive colon-semicolon substitutes (abbreviated ProEthica style guide; apply in Section C)

Template Variables

{{ guideline_text }} {{ guideline_title }} {{ existing_provisions }} {{ existing_principles }} {{ existing_obligations }}

Output Schema

provision_code: Section reference (e.g., "II.1.c")
provision_text: Full provision text
provision_category: fundamental_canons, rules_of_practice, etc.
establishes: List of Principle/Obligation IRIs

Service File

app/services/guideline/guideline_concept_integration_service.py

Version Info

Version: 2
Updated: 2026-05-27 09:50